Skip to main content

Is history repeating itself? - 832


1)  What are the similarities or differences in the motivation, community reactions, and legal outcomes in any of the hate crimes presented this week (the weblinks and the Chin case) and the runout/burnout periods that you have studied before?   

The similarities between the runout/burnout periods and the Asian American hate crimes is primarily due to economic supply-demand reasons. Asians are often willing (or need) to work under lower pay and sub-par conditions that a white or fairly-unionized worker would not go for. Thus, they are perceived to take both jobs and fair work conditions away from white workers. The main difference is that for the Chin case, the Asians were able to seemingly build a national civil rights platform - while in the earlier cases, the various hate crimes seems scattered across the country. 

2)  Why do you think there is little known about Asian American hate crimes?  

Little is known about Asian American crimes because Asian people generally do not have the time or “underemployment availability” in order to publicize it. Marketing takes a lot of effort and Asian people often don’t prefer “negative-connotion” marketing, preferring to present the race as a strong front without any compromises - such as being endangered due to civil rights crimes or being impoverished and living in sub-par conditions due to lack of resources. From my personal experience from my family, even Asians who are impoverished would often avoid welfare systems because they are too proud to admit they need it. Thus, people don’t usually perceive Asian people as a subjugated race, as compared to African people.  


***Post Election/current administration hate crimes: 
Regardless of your stance with the current administration, my concern within this class, all of my classes is to ensure that everyone feels safe, heard and respected.  Please be aware/respectable of the differences of opinion in this space as you answer this last question:
There have been many hate crimes across the US.  There is fear felt by many in this nation.  Are these hate crimes a result of the same forces that have motivated the ones in the past? (Think about what the main motivations were during the run-out/burnouts time). 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Second Wave

1) What are the main differences between the first wave Chinese and the post 1965 Chinese immigrants? (Lists are fine) Second Wave vs First Wave - Post 1965 immigrants, had better gender balance as they were past the days of the exclusion laws.   - Many immigrants were better educated, not exploited for entry to meet burgeoning pre-industrial revolution high demands of cheap labor.   - They were also more ready to take on urban civilization, being already accustomed to cities, rather than rural environments.   - Came from all areas of China, rather than just the impacted areas in first wave.   - Finally, the numbers. Not mere thousands or hundreds, but millions. 1 million in 1965 to 14 million in 2010   2) What are the main differences between an ethnic enclave and an ethnoburb? a)How do they function differently?  b) Why would one choose to live in one over the other? (Who lives in each location).  An ethnic encl...
Post a Comment
Read more

First Wave Chinese Immigrants

Part 1 1) What do the Chinese agricultural worker and the agricultural workers of today have in common? (Think in terms of contributions, need for labor, and treatment of laborers). 2) What do Asian owned businesses of today such as: nail shops, convenient stores, gas stations, and dry cleaning businesses all have in common with the laundrymen of the past? (Think about how/why would they enter into these types of businesses? Is it a skillset brought over from the homeland? A "trend"/niche that a couple people learned and trained their fellow countryment to do?) Part 2 In the Choy, Takaki and Kwong texts, the role of associations within the Chinatowns were discussed. Membership depended on surname, village, district, and sometimes through initiation. Kwong's text provided a deeper examination of the internal conflicts that these associations face amongst members, as well as with the Chinatown community whereas Choy allowed for examination of specific associations within S...
1 comment
Read more